The ICSA today held a protest at the Department of Agriculture building in Dublin, against the proposed EID sheep tagging system.
Member of the ICSA sheep committee met today at the department of agriculture HQ on Kildare Street, to showcase their disapproval at EID tagging and the clean sheep policy.
ICSA sheep chairman John Brooks said that the Minister’s unilateral decision to impose mandatory electronic tags (EID) on lambs destined for factories was the straw that broke the camel’s back.
“There is neither rhyme nor reason to the Minister’s decision to impose mandatory electronic tagging on lambs going directly to the factory. The traceability requirement is that they are tagged before they leave the farm. A few hours later, the lamb is processed with the ear disposed of and the costly electronic ear tag is in the skip. “, Mr. Brooks said today.
“This decision is set to add €2.5 million in costs to sheep farmers, based on additional costs of €1/lamb and a throughput of some 2.5 million lambs/ annum. However, the average profit per lamb is about €14, based on an annual average price of €100 or €4.80/kg over the past five years. It costs the average Teagasc profit monitor farmer €86 to produce a lamb. So, when the Minister adds €1 cost to a lamb producing €14 profit, he is imposing a 7% income cut. This compares badly with EU proposals to cut CAP direct payments by 4%.”, Brooks added.
Mr Brooks continued by saying that the proposal for a one-off payment of €50 was really rubbing farmers up the wrong way.
“Does the Minister really believe we can be bought off for €50? You’d give it to a youngster for their holy communion, but it doesn’t make up for a permanently imposed cost leading to a 7% cut in sheep farmers’ profits. That’s on lowland farms. The situation is even worse for hill farmers who are being asked to fund an extra euro when selling store lambs from the hills that might only be worth €20-30.”, he said.
The protest is also on the back of farmer anger over the clean sheep policy which has been imposed without any concern for the problems it has caused in factories this year. Mr. Brooks called for an urgent review of the implementation of these policies.
“We need an urgent review of the implementation of the policy as we cannot allow a repeat of the chaos we have seen on occasion in factories with whole consignments of lambs being sent off for shearing.”, he said.
“It is incumbent on the Department to pull all stakeholders together to develop a consensus on what will work in practice. It is especially important that Teagasc develop and trial systems of production that will ensure farmers can comply with requirements. Farmers need certainty and there is a lot of anger about the lottery of sending lambs in to a factory not knowing what will happen to them.”, he added.
ICSA have requested an urgent meeting with the Minister and the association is insisting that it’s back to the drawing board for compulsory EID for lambs and for the clean sheep policy.